Captain Cecil G. Judge
With General Dunsterville in Persia and Transcaucasia
The party from
Their destination was in
The object of the mission which is known as Dunsterforce were both offensive and defensive in their nature and speaking broadly, were to prevent the enemy reaching Afghanistan and India, by creating in the Caucasus a force to oppose to the Central Powers.
One of the deeply laid pre-war
schemes of the Germans was the penetration of the
There was, however in another
way in which the penetration of the Middle East could be effected - this was
by means of the railway running eastwards through the Caucasus from Batum to Baku – and beyond the Caspian from Krasnovodsk to Bokhara.
If passage for small parties of officers and other troops could be secured
along these railways,
The scheme of
This project also was doomed
to failure while the Russian Army operating in the
Until the summer of 1917 the Russian battle line held
firm from the Eastern shores of the
By the autumn of 1917 the
dire effects of the Russian revolution had spread to the troops operating
Thus in a few months the enemies of the Turks and Germans had practically vanished. They had either become ardent pacifists, politicians or isolated groups of soldiers heartily tired of war, and intent on returning to their own homes at all costs, and as quickly as possible.
The Turk quickly seized this opportunity for securing a bloodless victory. Gradually his troops began to work their way along the Caucasian rail way and it seemed towards the end of 1917 that the Turk would soon be planted firmly in the Caucasus and that German officers and non-commissioned officers would soon be making themselves prominent among the frontier tribes of India.
There appeared to be one method left open for checkmating the advancing enemy.
A scheme then, which promised
well was to send a part of selected officers to
The plan was distinctly practical, original, full of possibilities and if it failed the losses in personnel would not be very great.
To the officers of this force delightful prospects seemed to be offered – a new type of warfare, a new country and the leadership of men, and unruly perhaps, but nevertheless likely to make efficient soldiers. It was expected that the Armenians would fight with the utmost enthusiasm against their Mahommedan oppressors and the rest of the Caucasians seemed likely to provide most interesting material. Originally the Russians in the area under discussion had consisted of man outlawed by European Russia. Membership of an outlawed tribe was open to men of any description whatever provided they possessed the following qualifications: - the Orthodox Greek faith, ability to fight, and zeal in the gentle art of plunder. What glorious regiments could have been recruited from such men in 1916?
Unfortunately the ambitions of the Dunsterforce in this direction were never realised – by the time that section of the party which had come from France, reached Baghdad by way of Italy, Suez and the Gulf of Basrah, all allied activities in Tiflis had been precluded by the arrival there of Turkish regiments. (It had been expected originally that the party would somehow or other have to pass through territory occupied by Turks and remain isolated from other Allied troops for perhaps two years).
But the most unfortunate
circumstance of all, and the factor which made the scheme of reaching
The result of all this was
that no useful object could be attained in persevering in the attempt to
An alternative plan, and the only one likely to yield fruitful results
was to reach
Area of activities of the Dunsterforce mission. Main towns and locations mentioned in this text are shown by numbers:
Thus the object of the Dunsterforce now became to reach
The record of how these two grave difficulties mentioned above, were overcome, would fill at least four goodly sized volumes, and would form one of the most romantic stories of the whole war.
To deal first of all with the Persian question.
The result of all this was that after the Russians had withdrawn the country was in a deplorable condition. The Dunsterforce found in the towns people dying in hundreds and even many dead along the roads. The area of land under cultivation had shrunk to a considerable extent and villages once large and prosperous had practically disappeared. There was in the country enough grain to keep the greater part of the people alive, but that grain was in the hands of the wealthy landowners and merchants who, in the absence of any system of control, demanded exorbitant prices which the poor could never pay.
Law and order did not exist.
There was a police force, the influence of which was negligible as was the
authority of the Central Government. Robbers terrorised
and plundered individual travellers and even
whole villages. The large landholders with their disorderly retainers, plundered their less fortunate neighbours. The situation may be compared to that stage
in English history when “each man did what seemed good in his own eyes and
also a great deal which he knew to be absolutely wrong”. The nation was without
unity. Nominally their Shah and the Central Cabinet were the rulers of the
country, but orders from
As the result of the constant
interference and inroads of foreigners, Turks, Russians, Germans and Austrians
there arose gradually a sentiment of
The first party of the Dunsterforce consisting of General Dunsterville and a few officers reached
This town is situated on
the main road running from
The officers and NCO’s of the party were received with the utmost suspicion
by all classes of the community. It was thought that they were the advance
guard of invaders, such as the Russians and Turks had been. Hostile meetings
were held in the mosques and inflammatory placards were posted up in the
streets. No actual attack was made however, - the mob lacked a leader and
on several occasions it was this factor alone which saved the force from
the extermination. The whole of the
The General issued proclamations
stating that he had come to help the inhabitants and help them to once more
regain their former prosperity. At first the typical response was: – “the
British general says he comes to bring peace and prosperity! Did we ask
for it? Let him keep his peace and prosperity till we demand it.
The Persians soon began
to realize that the words of the British were not merely a bid for safety.
As soon as the snow on the mountains passes melted, a few lorry loads of wheat
seed were somehow got through from
It make seem that the problem
as to how 16 Britishers (15 of whom did not speak
Persian) managed to get an unorganized mob of about 6,000 Persians started
at “working on roads”, presented some difficulty, and it did! A proclamation
was printed stating that all who were willing to road work for the British
at a wage of 3 krans per day,
were to come to a certain spot outside the town at next morning. On the following day the mob
turned out in their hundreds and their eagerness to be selected, almost killed
the officers concerned – no work was done that day. On the second day an effort
was made to issue tickets to the more emaciated natives to entitle them to
collect pay at the end of the day’s work – again there was a stampede and
more work was done.
”I was not pleased,” – says General Dunsterville, “at this repeated lack of success and explained to the officer in charge that it was simply owned to his lack of intelligence.” “Colonel Duncan (Chief Staff officer to the General) quite agreed with my reproaches and added - the mistake you made is in not making the men sit down. Once they are sitting it is quite easy to keep order.” “Next day I received a despairing message from the officer-in-charge, that he was powerless to do anything with the mob. I replied that I would send Colonel Duncan out to show him how to do it; so Colonel Duncan forthwith proceeded and after making some such remark as “Now, you watch me”, addressed the crowd in Persian as follows: - “Sit down, sit down, sit down. Nothing till you sit down. Sit down”. Whereupon the crowd of several thousands, sat down then the interpreter announced “The Gentlemen will now give tickets to those who are entitled to work. No one must move – all must remain seated.” Perfect order reigned and a triumphant smile enlivened the features of the Staff Officer. “Now all you have to do is to go round with a bundle of tickets and issue them to the most hungry looking”. With that remark he stepped forward with one ticket in his hand to demonstrate the process. In one moment the whole 6,000 were on top of him and he returned sadder but wiser, admitting another failure, after having been severely trampled on”.
Eventually a satisfactory method of distribution was found securing the co-operation of the local civil authorities. As soon as this plan for the payment of the men began to work satisfactorily the starving children – those of say, the age from 4-10 years – were fed. The mothers as a rule brought their children, each of who had an earthenware bowl. They were collected into a closed yard, lined up, and made to file past a cauldron from which each received a bowl of soup. When one batch had received its soup, it was removed to a different yard and another batch took its place.
The work of famine relief was not allowed to go on without opposition. For instance, the bakers closed their shops or demanded still higher prices stating (quite falsely) that “the British had bought all available wheat for their army”. Tickets were forged and a certain amount of illegal traffic in tickets always existed. Contractors who supplied the British with goods were imprisoned. Each of these difficulties in turn was met and overcome and in a month a considerable improvement was noticeable in the condition of the people. In three months dead persons in the streets were rarely seen.
Gradually a change came
over the people of
A very efficient intelligence
system was organised. Trustworthy agents were
obtained and in a couple of months, the British at
As succeeding drafts of
the Dunsterforce arrived, a more aggressive policy
was adopted. In reality the fighting strength of the force was negligible,
but by audacity, results were obtained which under ordinary circumstances,
would have required in the district and town of
The need of troops was always
keenly felt by the force and to some extent the difficulty was relieved by
recruiting several bodies of levies. The Persians were totally unsuited for
warfare against Turkish troops, but when led few British officers were effective
in dealing with robber bands and in rounding up Turkish and German emissaries.
They were also utilised for garrison duties at
dangerous points on the roads. The activities of these levies had to be supervised
as carefully as possible. Sometimes robbers were inadvertently enlisted
whose object was to secure a uniform and hence authority to carry on robbery
(formally unauthorized) under the guard of authority. The Democratic Party
did everything in its power to hinder recruiting stating that to serve the
English was to incur everlasting disgrace and that the assassin’s knife would
punish any who did so. This opposition had but little effect and recruiting
proceeded favourably. A number of levies far in
excess of the actual requirements could have been obtained. In the neighbourhood of
One factor which had a considerable effect in securing the safety of the British at this time was the presence of a number of Russian soldiers who had not yet succeeded in returning home. They hated and were hated by the native and bore no particular love from the British. The native population seems to have had the feeling that if the British were attacked, the Russians might take the side of the white man. The Russian troops, with the exception of Bicherakov’s Cossacks were totally disorganised and infected with Bolshevism – they appear to have had no reasons for being Bolshevik rather than Menshevik - they adopted it, evidently, because it was the fashion of the hour, and the most favorable doctrine to secure their return home. The political views of the Russian soldier – and political views alone mattered – were somewhat as follows: - “Formerly we were ill-treated and oppressed. Then came the Revolution. Now we are free but unfortunately we are also ignorant. We don’t know how to rule ourselves. I accept what the last speaker says. I want to go home. Kazian, the exit from this benighted country is in the hands of the Bolshevik, therefore I am a Bolshevik”. Such men as these were the menace rather than an assistance to the British for any suspicion of an alliance between Briton and Russian caused the Persian to project the justly arose suspicion which he entertained for the latter, on to the former as well. The Cossacks of Bicherakov though to some extent affected with Bolshevism, and anxious to return home, were more useful allies. They were under some sort of discipline and were fairly efficient. Every assistance possible was afforded the unattached Russians to leave the country and General Dunsterville persuaded Colonel Bicherakov, by promises of future help in the Caucasus and by advances for the payment permit of his troops, to remain in Persia until the whole of the Dunsterforce had arrived, together with a few companies of the 39th Infantrny Brigade, part of which eventually reached Baku and took place in the operations there.
The activities of the Dunsterforce in famine relief, the establishment of
an efficient intelligence system, the raising of levies, the capture of many
enemy agents and the restoration of a semblance of law and order, build up
a strong British position in
As soon as
The great opposition met
The Jungalis as their name implies are a forest tribe inhabiting the
The Jungalis themselves had suffered less from famine than
most other parts of
Their leader, Kuchik-Khan was undoubtedly a patriot, though a dreamer striving earnestly for the welfare of his country. His ideals of liberty, fraternity, and equality and confusion to all foreigners. His people ardently hated the Russians but at the outbreak of the Revolution this hatred was temporarily laid aside on account of the Socialistic views of both peoples. Kuchik appointed a committee to assist him in the government of the country. Soon the committee governed Kuchik and eagerly received German gold and the German officers who reorganised and led the Jungali troops. Being Mahommedans the latter were favorably disposed towards the Turks.
The motives which actuated
the Jungalis were, in reality, not so much the
local Monroe Doctrine, as German gold and Mahommedan
religion. They were in close touch with the democrats of other provinces and
cities including the capital and had the sympathy of many leading civil officials.
The Central Government possessed no reliable fighting force and it seemed
likely at one time that Kuchik-Khan might easily
overthrow the cabinet of the Shah, and establish a revolutionary Government
As has been stated, there
was a considerable amount of sympathy between the Gelanis
and the Bolsheviks. The Bolsheviki were anti
British chiefly because the British Government would not recognize them as
the Government of Russia. The Gelanis were also
hostile to the British because they feared that the latter would take the
place of the departing Russians and would prolong the war. Thus at
The passage of the disorganized Russians homewards along the forest road was expedited by Kuchik and with the advice of his German officers he also offered to assist Bicherakov, provided the latter renounced all connection with the English – a proposal which was scornfully rejected.
It is estimated that the
It is true that the Dunsterforce used every possible means to avoid conflict with the Jungalis - not from motives such as the Germans imputed – but because there was nothing to be gained by fighting a tribe with whom we were not very much concerned. We had no great interest in their domestic affairs. All that was desired was an unimpeded passage through their country and the release of certain officers whom they had captured and imprisoned. Lengthy negotiations produced no useful results and so the assistance of Bicherakov was obtained in order to force a way through.
In June 4th Kuchik-Khan with his force was occupying the strong defensive position at Menzil. He was well provided with machine guns and ammunition, and his 5000 infantry occupying well sighted trenches should have been sufficiently numerous to resist a division.
Bicherakov’s brigade was a composite force of all arms consisting of Infantry, Cavalry and a section of field guns. To this brigade were attached a few officers and N.C.O.s of the Dunsterforce, several armored cars and two aeroplanes. An important point of the Menzil position was a spur running out from the mountains causing the road to make a hair pin bend. On the approach of Bicherakov’s infantry the Jungalis occupying this position turned and fled. When the artillery opened fire on the hill entrenchments to the west of the road there was noticed, first of all individuals moving towards the rear, and then parties of 5 or 6 departing with unseemly haste. The aeroplanes machine gunned the entrenchments causing great consternation. The Cossack infantry then attacked and in a couple of hours the position was in the hands of Bicherakov. The losses of the attackers were very slight. The defenders became totally disorganized and abandoned the greater part of their machine guns and ammunition and disappeared into the forest.
From this time it became
possible for Ford vans carrying troops and supplies, even without armored
car escort, from Menzil to Enzeli. Two companies of 4th, 1/2nd Gurkhas and a Company of the 1/4th Hampshire Regiment
brought up from
A rather serious attack
on the British garrison at
From this time onward no opposition was experienced from the Jungalis and eventually peace was made. Kuchik-Khan agreed to forego hostile propaganda, dismissed his German officers and allowed the British to pass unmolested through his country.
The events mentioned have
been described in a certain sequence and without detail in order to make an
exceedingly brief account, as clear as possible, but it must not be supposed
that the undivided efforts of the Dunsterforce
were directed towards reaching
To the south and west of
After the Caucasian army melted away these people were surrounded by two Turkish divisions and very hard pressed. They nevertheless put up an excellent fight against great odds, and actually won several victories. They did not yield through fear of massacre and because they hoped that the British would be able to send them assistance.
The Turk held the country
The Jilus succeeded in getting a messenger to the Dunsterforce at Bijar asking for rifles ammunition and money. A reply was sent by aeroplane to the effect that rifles and ammunition would be sent to Sain Kaleh and the Jilus and Armenians were requested to force a way through the surrounding Turks and meet a squadron of cavalry at Sain Kalekh bringing the rifles and ammunition. This they succeeded in doing.
however, made the fatal mistake of sending on the expedition too great a proportion
of his fighting man. Rumors were circulating by the enemy agents in Urmieh that the whole force had been slaughtered. These
reports were believed. At this juncture the whole population seems to have
become panic-stricken and with their cattle and belongings
made a wild stampede in the direction of Bijar
and thence into
They were hopelessly disorganised and without provisions and protection. Those who were mounted (on oxen, horses, or mules or donkeys) traveled fastest. The courageous spirit hitherto displayed by their fighting men, seemed to have disappeared when the whole population formed a fleeing rabble. No help was afforded the old men, women and children – many died by the roadside. The road followed was for weeks afterwards distinguishable on account of dead bodies.
The soldiers among them put up no resistance and were always well to the front, ready to plunder Kurdish villages passed on the way. The angry Kurds followed in the rear of the column destroying the helpless.
A mounted party of about
twelve officers and NCO’s with three Lewis
guns was sent to their assistance. The party was far too small but no larger
force was available and they could only bring a few thousand pounds of flour
to give the starving fugitives. The officer in charge was Captain S. Savige D.S.O., M.C., of the 24th Australian
Infantry Bn and he and his officers and NCO’s performed exploits of which
In this disastrous flight from 20,000 to 25,000 Armenians and Jilus met their fate.
When the fugitives arrived
in the neighborhood of
After the defeat of Kuchik-Khan no further opposition was experienced in
Three transports were secured
at Enzeli – the “Abo”,
At this point it may fairly
be said that the British were undoubtedly masters of the northern half of
the Country. A strong position had in few months been built up in spite of
difficulties of every description – bad roads, an unhealthy climate in which
typhus and cholera were prevalent, hostility of Persians and Gelanis, Bolshevik propaganda, shortage of food, and
shortage of the petrol needed for transport on the 600 miles of road between
The Armenian National Council
Politically the strength
of the Armenians at
The Turkish question had
become very serious by the end of June – 12,000 of their troops, – half regulars
and half levies, were advancing along the trans-Caucasian railway from
The Armenians had every
reason to suppose that the latter would succeed in their object unless the
Bolshevik government were overthrown. They accordingly
effected a coup d’etat
and overthrew the government establishing in its place a government headed
by 5 “Dictators”. Thirteen shiploads of Bolsheviki
left the city and sailed for
had previously taken his force to
He newly appointed “Dictators”
asked for the assistance of the Dunsterforce
and all available troops. General Dunsterville
willingly granted their request but pointed out that the troops at his disposal
were not sufficient for the defense of the town and that the
The city had a population of about 300,000 composed of Russians, Tartars and Armenians and also a few Georgians and Greeks. The houses are many (sic) of them magnificent structures built in European style. The large Russian Cathedral in the centre of the town is very picturesque. The streets are generally fairly wide and in peace time must have been well kept. They are paved with cobble stones and there was formerly an efficient tram service. The city is situated in a large hollow with ground gradually rising to a line of cliffs to the north and east. The country in the neighborhood is barren except where very beautiful rows of trees have been planted. There are three chief groups of oil wells at Bibi Eibat, Balakhani and at Binagadi. The crude oil is refined at what is known as Black town where there are also large oil and petrol reservoirs.
The civil government was very week. Although a large number of Bolsheviki had left the town, many remained, and apart from this every department was run by committees. The numbers of these bodies were rarely specialists and as a result wasted enormous amount of time in discussing and passing resolutions when they should have been acting. Even when resolutions were passed there was no authority to ensure that they would be carried out. The majority of the citizens were tired of the continued disorder, and were prepared to support any scheme likely to give stability and security. It has been well said that “revolutionaries are quite the least brotherly people towards each other that the world contains, and constitute a living refutation of their fundamental doctrines”. A remarkable fact is that the Bolsheviki strongly anti-British before our arrival, became some of our strongest supporters – evidently because we were found to be reliable and represented money and armed strength.
Food was scarce and prices were high. Everything had been nationalised and there was no inducement for private merchants to import foodstuffs. A very frugal meal in a hotel cost somewhere in the neighborhood of two pounds at the current rate of exchange. In addition to the scarcity, the method of distribution among the civil population seems to have been bad.
Methods such as the methods of the civil government and the food supply and the economic position of the town have been mentioned not because they are at all interesting, but because they always have considerable influence on the situation in a besieged town.
At the time the British arrived the length of line held by the defenders was about 21,000 yards. The left flank touched the sea from which a cliff running northwards for about seven miles was held. Thence the cliff turned inwards to the defenses but the line was continued northwards for about another three miles to a hill called Dirty Vulcan. From there it turned eastwards to Binagadi village and to Diga. The right flank of the defence rested at a salt lake about three quarters of a mile north-east of Diga. The line was far too close to the town and should have run directly north and south across the peninsula. The front was not wired, the trenches were far too shallow and neither communication, support or reserve trenches existed at all. The infantry numbered about 6,000 and were divided into 22 battalions ranging in strength from 150 to 250 men. The battalions were not organized, the food and ammunition supply was poor and there were few local officers of experience. There were a few squadrons of cavalry, and a number of batteries ranging in size from the mountain guns to 5-inch field guns. These were mostly antiquated and of various patterns.
Shortly before the Turkish attack on Baku:
left - Russian and Armenian soldiers near the front line; right - trianing
of local troops (photos from the Collection of Australian War Memorial)
The deplorable nature of the defenses was an indication of the worth of the troops. The most reliable of them were Russians but there was no discipline whatever. There were committees. The committees frequently could not get their orders carried out. The officers had no authority. The writer once asked a Russian soldier why he had not carried out an order given him by his Russian officer. His reply was “Why should I do what he tells me? He is just a private soldier like myself and I don’t think that what he says is a good plan”. It might have been expected that the Armenian soldiers would have been models of determination and courage. They were neither. In the course of conversation they used to say: “Yes, you are right. If we don’t hold this line the Turk will soon be in the town, slaughtering our wives and children. We will defend this position to the last” -brave words which were never fulfilled by acts. When an attack developed all protestations would be forgotten. They would fade away to the rear leaving their machine guns in the hands of the enemy. Frequently a soldier regarded the machine gun which he was supposed to work, as his own personal property, and when he felt inclined to do so, would return to the city taking the gun with him.
Their leaders were hardly superior in martial qualities to the rank and file though there were a few really efficient and enthusiastic officers among them. The following is an illustration of the sort of army we were obliged to work with and assist. “I received” says General Dunsterville, “an invitation from the Russian commander in chief to be present at at a Council of War. I replied that I was not in favor of such councils, but if it was decided to hold one, I should be glad to be present. I found the Commander in Chief at the central table with maps spread before him and he offered me a sit at his side. The entire room was filled with the members of the various committees. The Armenian National Council was there in full force, the five Dictators, Workmen’s delegates, Soldiers’ and Sailors’ delegates, and Peasant Deputies. It did not appear likely that a Council of War held on these lines was going to achieve anything useful. The proceeding commenced by the General giving a very clear but lengthy appreciation of the situation, his remarks being punctuated by interpolations of assent or disapproval from the members of the various committees. He was, however, permitted to conclude his address without serious interruption and summed up his remarks by saying “The enemy have taken A and B and will probably next move on to C which will make D untenable. I therefore propose that we alter the whole line as follows”.
Before the concluding remarks were out of his mouth a burly sailor strode up to the table to give his views on the situation. He made use of the General’s map indicating points as required by the use of his broad thumb, oblivious of the fact that his thumb covered more than a square mile of country, leaving some of his points rather vague. He spoke for an hour with obvious enjoyment, repeating himself a good deal and wandering off the track every now and then to work in some very well worn tag or to give vent to some such sentiment as “we will fight to the very last drop of our blood” which produced vociferous applause. He eventually arrived in the approved manner, at his summing up, which was the exact contrary of that of the commander in chief, and he suggested plans of action which were quite the reverse of those outlined by the commander in chief, and urged the taking up of a line totally different.
His final peroration was to the following effect: “The general says the Turks are holding such and such points. That is not so, the line runs thus (describing the enemy’s imaginary line with considerable detail). He says we have had to give up B. That is not so. I have just had a telephone message form a friend of mine out there. The General says we must take up such and such a line. He is quite wrong. That is not the line to take up. This is the one (more detail). His Counsel is not that of a brave man. We mean to fight to the bitter end & c”.
To my surprise the general in no way resented this amateur interference with his plans, in fact he seemed to think there was a good deal in what the sailor said.
When the speaker reluctantly resumed his seat, the Armenian National Council had their say, proposing plans neither agreeing with those of the commander in chief, nor with those of the sailor. After them the Dictators had quite a fresh plan to propose, differing from all the others. The Dictators were followed by other speakers each with his own views to put forward and each inspired by a desire to continue talking so long as his breath held out.
So time went on until the clock struck one and my patience was exhausted. How long the meeting continued I do not know but having decided that it was quite time for my stuff and myself to be in bed, I apologized quietly to my commander in chief and withdrew, leaving the assembly to continue their futile discussions.
All this is rather amusing but it is pathetic when one remembers that warfare conducted on such lines contributed to the death of gallant British soldiers.
The Turks at this time were occupying a line in most places about 2,000 yards distant. It is not known definitely what troops were at their disposal but were probably in the neighbourhood of 10,000 including cavalry and artillery. Some of their regiments were fairly good but they had a large number of levies who were unreliable. A large number of Tartars from the city itself and from the surrounding villages had joined the Turks, and though they were mostly civilians, they were of considerable use on account of their knowledge of the locality. It is certain that there were numerous enemy agents within the city, who could easily get through the lines and it probable that they had direct telephone communication to the Turkish forces.
Bicherakov had arrived in the city three weeks before the British; after taking part in a series of engagements in which he had been worsted through the work of co-operation and determination of the part of the “Red Army”, he withdrew his detachment to Derbent 100 miles further to the North.
There is one noteworthy event in the series of depressing and futile operations in which alone the Armenians displayed a little enthusiasm and aggressiveness. On July 30th “the Red Army”, i.e. the local troops, and the Cossacks had been driven back some distance leaving the enemy in possession of the heights above the town, and within 3000 yards of the wharves. A rumour spread among the Turks to the effect that a large cavalry force had appeared in their rear. They commenced to retire. The Armenians pursued with considerable vigour and regained the important positions they had lost, but instead of “digging in” the majority of them returned to the town to stroll round the promenades and relate to admiring lady friends their gallant deeds.
The withdrawal of Bicherakov left a gap in the extreme right of the defences and this gap was never filled. The local authorities complained bitterly of this action but had done nothing to fill this gap during the three weeks which had elapsed prior to the arrival of the British.
Bicherakov was concerned more with the security of his own force than the safety of the city, that the withdrawal was a great mistake and really sealed the fate of the city. If he had remained the town would never have fallen.
The British force of approximately 1000 men consisting of detachment
of the 9th
Fourteen officers of the Dunsterforce were attached to local units. Six of these were artillery officers and were given command of local batteries. They produced a considerable amount of improvement in the shooting and general efficiency of the personnel. The men became more soldierly and learnt a good deal about their job and became devoted to their English leaders. The local artillery through the instructional work of these few officers, and the more general organising work of two officers of the Headquarters Staff of the Dunsterforce, became quite the most efficient arm of the Service.
The eight Infantry officers were attached as “assistant commanders”
to local battalions and brigades of infantry. It is due to their efforts that
the greater part of the front was wired. Their units dug improved front line
trenches organised into systems and also many communication trenches. Good
machine gun positions were constructed and our headquarters in
The following is typical of the kind of work which had to be done: “On going round the line I find a machine gun in an impossible position. I interview the Commanding Officer and persuade him to move it to So and So to-night. I then search out the officer in charge of the gun and after a few polite, and, as far as possible, cheerful remarks say - “This machine gun is useless here because _____. Tonight I would like you to move it to such and such position”. The officer decides that the proposed position would be excellent and agrees to move it that very night. In order to make sure that the matter won’t be forgotten I see the machine gun crew and tell them the gun is to [be] moved to ____ to-night. In my inexperience I at first expect that the instructions will be carried out. Next day I find that for some childish reason, nothing has been done and if I want particularly to have that gun moved, I have to go along at an appointed hour, collect the gun, officer and crew, mark out the emplacement, and stay until the job is done. There is a good deal of unnecessary work attached to this sort of thing and even though I have to hasten of a quantity of other work as well, I receive but little assistance”.
Still, the defences and the bearing of the troops in a short time showed considerable improvement, and if the final Turkish attack had been delivered three weeks later, after the re-organisation of the defenders had been completed and the line further strengthened we should have been able, without doubt, to save the city.
It is not possible to give a complete account of the operations
of the various units raised in
The British troops fared badly on account of becoming dangerously exposed because of failures on the part of their allies, or because the latter did not support them when a crisis arose.
On August 26 about 1000 of the enemy attacked Dirty Vulcan which
was held by D Coy of the 9th
On August 31st the Turks attacked and captured Binagadi Hill which was held by one company of British. The Armenians in reserve at Binagadi village, not only failed to give support, but even drifted towards the rear. Once more the English casualties were heavy and the only consolation which remains is that the enemy suffered much more heavily.
A final general attack was delivered by the enemy on 14th September.
Information was received of their intentions about 36 hours previously from an Arab deserter. Suitable dispositions were made through the line but only one company of the British were withdrawn from the forward area to form a dependable general reserve.
The chief attack was delivered at dawn at Wolfes Gap - naturally a strong defensive position about 500 yards from the extreme left flank, and held by the Red Army, - and also at Beladjari village held by the Worcesters and an Armenian unit. Holding attacks were also delivered at other points of the line and had a rather demoralising effect on the local units concerned.
The troops at the Wolfes Gap put up no resistance whatever. A regiment of cavalry penetrated the breach in that line and reaching the plateau above the city, caused havoc among the artillery. By the enemy were in possession of the houses on the eastern outskirts of the town.
The great part of the “Red Army” put up a feeble resistance and
in some cases bolted for
The regiment in the neighbourhood of Beladjari Station – a unit of about 1200 Russians and Armenians – beat off all enemy attacks, delivered a partly successful counter attack to help the regiment on its left and was with difficulty withdrawn to new line after having been almost surrounded. This was the only praiseworthy achievement which the citizen army can claim.
The British company in general reserve delivered, in the direction of Wolfes Gap, a counter attack of which any Englishman may well be proud; but perhaps the prospect of about 120 men without artillery support, advancing against 2000 well armed enemies is pathetic rather than glorious! The company suffered a large proportion of casualties but created a diversion which delayed the Turks in entering the city.
Counterattacks delivered by Russians had little effect and by it was obvious that the city was doomed. The troops were everywhere in disorder and dispirited. Most of their machine guns had been lost and in addition numerous field guns had been destroyed. The Dictators had begun to discuss surrender (the terms of which were agreed upon the following day).
General Dunsterville then decided to withdraw his troops, regarding further defence as futile. (The accuracy of this view is controversial as there was the possibility of withdrawing what was left of the tired British troops, bringing them and committing them to a final counterattack).
The wounded were safely placed on board a transport and at about the British Infantry together with the 8th battery R.F.A. and its guns were marched on to the “Kursk” and ”President Krueger” which were waiting in readiness.
By a continuation of good fortune and good management the surviving Dunsterforce officers attached to local units, were also notified of the intended departure and – with the exception of one officer and one sergeant who escaped with refugees to Krasnovodsk - embarked.
The transports succeeded in eluding the guardships stationed at the entrance of the harbour and by of the 5th of September had reached Enzeli.
On the conclusion of the Armistice with
* Lazar Fedorovich Bicherakov (Bicherahov) (1882 -1952) - Colonel of the Terskoye Cossack Force (Tsar Army). After 1918 - one of leaders and organizers of anti-Bolshevik activities in the Caucasus. From 1919 - White emigre. Lived in Germany, during WWII he was head of the North-Caucasus Section of the Committee of Liberated Peoples of Russia (KONR) - anti-Soviet organizations which co-operated with the Nazis.